I know this is an innocent question, but I can’t help jumping straight to the top of my soapbox. Really, have you ever met someone looking for a lower paying job? I feel like we need to have a very real conversation about what it takes to connect these dots.
I hope this sounds as warm, encouraging, and supportive as I intend for it to. I genuinely want to help you have this conversation with your son, and having 4 young-adult sons of my own who have recently navigated this transition to independence, I want to share my opinion. This is, as always, just my opinion. But since you asked….
When we think about how to making a very good living, I think we are overlooking the huge ramp-up that it takes to even get to making a modest living.
It takes a lot of work to earn a modest living. I think students overlook that the default position in life that they’ll start out unemployed! In other words, to make a “very good living” you’re going to have to beat all those already earning a modest living, and to beat those, you’re going to have to beat the unemployed. It takes a LOT of consistent hard work just to make show up every day and keep your job.
The median wage in the USA is $59,000. Median means exact “middle” which is not the same as “average.” In other words, if you lined up each and every person in the USA from lowest (all the people who earned zero each year) to the highest (which includes multi-millionaires) the person standing in the dead-center middle is earning $59,000. If you spend some time over at the US Department of Labor’s Occupational Outlook Handbook (free and excellent) you’ll see that lots, and lots, and lots of occupations that require a bachelor’s degree yet pay less than $59,000. In fact, I can find a dozen occupations that require a master’s degree and still earn under $59,000.
So if this is only a math problem, use the DOL filters, select a high paying career, and do that. Any of us could do that, but as it turns out, people have a strong opinions about how they spend the hours every day, so the variables of passion, preference, and purpose can’t be overlooked. To find passion, preference, and purpose, there aren’t any software filters on the computer- those have to come from your son’s heart and mind. And I have scary news, you can’t choose that for him. In fact, he might not even have the self-awareness to find this for himself yet. But, there is no short cut here. It might happen when he’s 18 or 28 or 48, but it’s not going to happen until he joins the conversation.
In my opinion, I think there are 3 ways to earn a “very good living” in this country, and the good news is that I think you can probably apply these principles to any field under the sun. Which is to say someone who is a musician or artist has as much of a shot of high income as someone who is a software engineer or nurse. I also believe it’s possible to mess up an otherwise excellent income potential career track when you’re lazy, distracted, or afraid. So it works both ways.
- Perfect a skill to the point of being an expert in a field where most people are not experts. The key is “where most people are not experts.” Often if you pursue a skill where most people can do the job relatively well, you make it that much harder on yourself. For instance, almost everyone who learns to cook professionally can also become a very good chef with minimal practice. The competition to be an expert will be crowded. This is demonstrated by the slim difference between a cook’s salary ($40,000) and that of a chef ($50,000). On the other side of the coin, many can learn to be a generally good mechanic, but very few can perfect the skills needed to become an expert mechanic in a specific industry. This is demonstrated by the significant difference between a general mechanic’s salary ($47,000) and the much higher pay associated with the salary of the experts like Aviation mechanic ($75,000) or Elevator mechanic ($102,000). Most people only look at the time and money required to become sufficient. If he is to become an expert, it may take twice as long (or more).
- Have a credential(s) so specialized that most people do not have this credential thus he will be in high demand. This is similar to the first point, but instead of having the expertise, this is specific to obtaining a credential. This is demonstrated by the significant differences in pay between someone working as a registered nurse ($86,000) and a nurse who became a Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetist ($208,000). We know there are 3 million nurses in the USA, but only 61,000 of them hold the CRNA credential. We could speculate that an extra credential like being a bilingual or sign language interpreter could further push the CRNA to the top of the income earners in the profession. Most people don’t have the tenacity to do very hard things. Hard can be academic, but it can also be dealing with difficult people, working long hours, moving to a different geographic area, or giving up a social life.
- Start your own business. Being an entrepreneur is incredibly difficult, most will fail, and many will say that an some people are just born entrepreneurs. That said, every job in the world has an earning cap, but starting your own business is limitless. Owning your own business can be as simple as offering goods or services (clothing store, chiropractor, real estate agent) to customers, or you can build something from scratch that has never existed until your idea came to be (YouTube, Apple, Amazon) but in both cases, you have the ultimate control over your own success. Depending on the industry, as many as 90% of new businesses can fail in their first year, but the ones that succeed can change the world.
U.S. Department of Labor Occupational Outlook Handbook
So what should you do?
- Explain to your son (and accept for yourself) that there is no perfect answer out there to find. Pressure to choose can be crippling when you think there is an answer and you can’t find it.
- Adjust his goals to align with his weaknesses. Everyone talks about strengths, but look at weaknesses as well. Someone who hates being a follower won’t thrive in a career that takes 10 years learning the ropes before experiencing autonomy.
- Know that college is expensive, and it may or may not be the best decision right now. But for sure he won’t know that until he does some serious introspection and decides what he wants out of this life.
In closing, I wanted to briefly share that I went to culinary school after high school and was exceptionally committed to becoming a successful chef. Once I got married (my husband is also a chef and we shared those goals when we met) and we started a family, becoming “successful” wasn’t my goal anymore. I wanted to be home for my kids, raise them, homeschool them, etc. While 17 year old me didn’t think being a wife and mother was important, 27 year old me thought it was the most important thing. My husband’s goals also matured, and he gave up glitz and glam for mundane things like health insurance and Saturdays off. The point of me telling you this is that I don’t think my story is all that unique. Trust that your son will also be able to handle the changes life throws his way, no matter what major he chooses this fall.
