Is there a “sweet spot” when most teens are ready to start earning college credit in high school? Here is a quick list of the college credit options and when most will start to use them.
When should my teen start earning college credit?
It’s hard to answer anything other than “it really depends on the student” which is true…. but not helpful. So, in this post, I want to help you learn when “most” people begin using various types of college credit and why.
Keep in mind, these are general suggestions; you know your teen better than I do!
Three questions about readiness:
- Academically: Is my teen academically ready to learn the subject?
- Emotionally: Does my teen have the emotional maturity to put the course content in context? Is this the first time my teen will be exposure to mature content?
- Socially: Is my teen ready to interact with, discuss, debate, and disagree with adult classmates? Do they understand how to relate among mixed-ages?
Homeschooling for College Credit recommends teens earn college credit in high school, but only if the parent feels the student is ready academically, emotionally, and socially.
CLEP Exams / DSST Exams (10th Grade +)
Best for students who are ready academically but maybe not emotionally or socially. The best part of earning college credit by exam (CLEP or DSST) is that you can take them at any age or grade. As a result, you’ll often see parents reporting that their younger teens have earned college credit this way while waiting to become eligible for dual enrollment or dual credit. HS4CC recommends taking credit by exam tests only after your teen has completed a high school course, but it isn’t required. It’s a good idea to know which CLEP exams line up with your regular high school courses so you can keep this in mind while planning. Teens who are strong test takers, strong readers, and otherwise solid academically will have no trouble taking a CLEP after every high school subject. Parents can accompany the student to the testing center (if using a testing center) but not sit in on the exam. CLEP and DSST both also offer home-based proctoring, which allows the student to take the exam in the comfort of their own home. (CLEP exams are currently free when you obtain a voucher from Modern States)
Advanced Placement Exams (11th Grade +)
Best for students who are ready academically and emotionally. AP Exams are different than CLEP exams in that the answers are written, not multiple choice. In addition, the exams are all given in person at a high school. So, like CLEP, your teen should be able to read, understand, and recall information from an 11th-grade or higher high school textbook, but they ALSO must be able to express their answer well using short essays and free response format. Their writing must be at a solid 11-12th-grade level to pass an AP exam successfully. They shouldn’t feel anxious about being in a high school, among high school students, or being addressed by high school authorities. The parent will not be allowed at the test location.
Dual Enrollment ON CAMPUS (mature 11th- 12th Grade)
Students must be ready academically, emotionally and socially. Dual enrollment courses taken on a college campus will take place in a classroom of adults learning a variety of topics. The course content will not be filtered, and instructors/professors generally are not informed about the age of any student. Expect content to include sexuality, violence, human rights, politics, religion, etc. Also, expect that your teen may be on the opposite side of their professor or classmates. On-campus classes require participation; your teen will not only be an observer in the class but may be expected to discuss, write, and present on various topics. See if you can preview the course textbook and syllabus to get an idea of potential problem topics. When in doubt, switch to online or wait. Hint: Even in classes without mature content (math, foreign language, culinary arts, etc.) are still going to include a mixed age class.
Dual Enrollment ONLINE (mature 10th Grade+)
Best for students who are ready academically and emotionally but not necessarily ready socially. In contrast to on-campus classes, online class discussions will not be face-to-face. An advantage is that your teen will avoid in-person peer pressure, inappropriate social situations, and group projects with much older adults. While the “content” will still contain adult themes in many classes, the online format gives parents oversight and the ability to guide the student from home. Online courses that are asynchronous (on your own time) allow your teen plenty of time to digest and discuss with a parent. Online synchronous courses will be more spontaneous as they are taught live remotely (Zoom, etc.) As with any college course, try to preview the textbook and syllabus ahead of time to get an idea of potential problem topics.
ACE Courses (13+)
Best for students who are ready academically but maybe not emotionally or socially. Companies like Straighterline, Studycom, Sophia, Saylor, and others offer totally autonomous on-demand courses that don’t have a professor. Most of these don’t require homework, papers, speeches, or classmate interaction. In fact, these courses are more like guided self-study than a class with students. Students often take proctored exams which require a webcam on the home computer, so there may be concerns surrounding privacy. While the topics may contain adult themes, your student will not interact with adults at any time, so their readiness is strictly academic.
