Posted in HS4CC

Too Much College Credit? Maybe!

HS4CC advises parents not to go beyond 30 college credits without a specific target in mind. There are many reasons for this sound advice, but in today’s post, I want to present some information about “Excess Credit Hour Policies” and “Federal Financial Aid’s 150% Rule” which could hit some students with too much college credit in the wallet.

Excess Credit Hour Policies” and “Federal Financial Aid’s 150% Ruleare related but distinct policies that limit the number of credit hours a student can attempt while still receiving certain tuition benefits or financial aid.

These are two different rules, but you should be aware of both.

  • Excess Credit Hour Policies: Encourage on-time graduation by imposing additional charges for credits above a set threshold. They are set by states or schools and vary widely.
  • Federal 150% Rule: Limits how long you can receive federal student aid to 150% of the required credits for your degree (e.g., 180 credits for a 120-credit program). Beyond that, you lose eligibility for most federal aid.

As an example, let’s say your student’s bachelor’s degree is typical and requires completion of 120 college credits. (About 40 classes)

https://shorturl.at/WQKf0

Excess credit hour policies penalize students who accumulate more than X number of credits beyond 120. In some states, like Florida outlined below, having only 12 extra credits will cause the public university to charge you TWICE the regular rate of tuition.

What Colleges Say

Colleges with financial penalties argue that they want students to graduate on time, they develop these policies with the student’s best interest in mind, and to “encourage” them to graduate on time so the college can “make way for incoming students.”

What Colleges Don’t Say

IPEDS (the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System) is a mandatory data collection that reports graduation data for every U.S. college or university participating in federal financial aid programs. (Public information, you can and should check graduation rates). Consistently low graduation rates look bad to the public. In addition, they can trigger scrutiny from accreditors, affect an institution’s reputation, and make it harder for the college to secure funding. In extreme cases (especially if paired with other compliance issues), a college can risk losing accreditation or eligibility for federal financial aid.

For example, if a bachelor’s degree program is designed to take four years (100% of normal time), IPEDS tracks how many students graduate within six years (150%) or eight years (200%).

When you read a college’s GRADUATION RATE, you are reading a rate of 150% time or higher. Meaning that number reflects how many students have graduated with a 4-year degree after 6 years.

If an institution reports low graduation rates year over year, this can signal deeper problems (poor academic quality, student support gaps, financial instability), and accreditors could place the institution on warning, probation, or, in rare circumstances, revoke accreditation.Loss of accreditation means the institution is no longer eligible for federal financial aid (Title IV funds). Follow the money…. if you can’t get funding to go to ABC College but you *can get it to go to XYZ University, where are you going to go?

Default Rate vs. Graduation Rate: Although there’s no direct cutoff tying federal aid to graduation rates alone, poor academic outcomes often correlate with high student loan default rates.

For 4-year colleges in the U.S., the average 150% graduation rate (i.e., graduating within 6 years) is typically in the low-to-mid 60% range.

For 2-year colleges (community colleges), the average 150% graduation rate (i.e., graduating within 3 years) generally falls around 30-35%.

Blame the Student

While this post doesn’t look into the specific details why a student might not graduate on time (or one and a half-time) it does call to action the student’s role in the process. In short, a student who has “too much credit” isn’t graduating on time. The college clearly isn’t taking ownership of their role (bad advising, schedule issues, etc.) but students who change majors may find themselves with a lot of “extra” and more importantly UNUSED college credit. It’s the unused college credit that is the problem. Credit not tied to a specific degree plan sits unused, and is counted as excess.

A college may “encourage” your student to use this credit by adding a minor, a double major, or otherwise spending more time (and money) with them. Proceed with caution, since an extra minor, major, or degree may not have the return on investment you hope for.

As a HS4CC family, the advice is to plan well and with intention once you have a target in mind. If you don’t yet have a target, keep your college credit earning under 30 credits. Once you do have a target, proceed with a plan to hit the target as efficiently and resourcefully as possible – ideally with little to no extra unused credits.

Author:

Founder & Executive Director of Homeschooling for College Credit, Inc.

Leave a Reply