Recording grades from multiple sources used different grade scales? This challenge can become even more complex if you want to streamline your entire transcript onto one scale. If your homeschooler has taken college classes, it’s likely you’ve encountered differences in how grades are assigned vs those you’ve already assigned. If that’s happened to you, this will help you clean up your transcript.
A parent asks:
“How do you handle grades when classes taken had different grading scales? My son has taken classes through online, in-person, and community college. One of the in-person classes awarded him his grade with a + or – attached. They used the grading scale of 80-82=B-; 83-86=B; 87-89= B+. All of his online classes used 80-89=B, (The A scale is a bit different since 93-100=A). When I first did the transcript, I computed the GPA using the same scale of the community college and in-person classes. Should I just keep it?”
This is a common situation that many homeschooling parents face, so let’s walk through how to address this thoughtfully.
Step 1: Define Your Homeschool as the “School of Record”
As the homeschool administrator, you have the authority to set the grading standards for your transcript. When a school, such as a private or public high school, receives transfer credits from various institutions, it often interprets these credits through its own grading scale. This is because each institution is essentially acting as the “school of record,” responsible for how grades and credits appear on their transcript. For homeschoolers, this means you’re the school of record, and you can decide how grades are awarded and recorded.
When you create your student’s transcript, think of it as a transfer process. Every credit awarded on your homeschool transcript is essentially being “transferred into” your homeschool, and it’s up to you to establish how to represent those credits. You can choose to either preserve each institution’s grading scale or adopt a single grading scale for your homeschool. Each choice has pros and cons, but consistency is the most important factor.
Step 2: Decide How to Handle the Plus and Minus Grades
In your situation, the primary question is whether to include or exclude the “+” and “-” variations in the grades, as this can impact your student’s GPA. Here are a couple of options:
- Preserve the Original Grades (Including + and -): Keeping the original grades as they were awarded—meaning if a class was graded as a B+ or an A-, you record it exactly that way—has the advantage of transparency. This approach can be particularly useful if a college might later reconcile your homeschool transcript with the official college transcript. Admissions offices are accustomed to seeing the + and – designations, so this can sometimes simplify the review process.
- Simplify to Straight Letter Grades: If you prefer a streamlined approach, you might choose to drop the + and – grades, recording each grade as a straight A, B, C, etc. This can make GPA calculations more straightforward, and some families feel that it reduces ambiguity in interpreting the final GPA.
Both approaches are valid, but the key is to be consistent. Whichever route you decide, apply it across the board and stick to it. This will prevent any confusion and ensure that the transcript is uniform and easy to understand.
Step 3: Select a GPA Scale and Apply It Consistently
Many grading scales are used by schools, so it’s up to you to choose one for your homeschool. You might select a common scale such as:
- Unweighted Scale (4.0 scale): Often, high schools use this scale where A=4.0, B=3.0, C=2.0, etc.
- Weighted Scale: If some of your student’s classes were at a college level, you might consider assigning extra weight to these classes (e.g., A=5.0) to acknowledge the additional rigor.
If your community college has used a grading scale that includes pluses and minuses, such as 3.7 for an A- and 3.3 for a B+, you can adopt this scale across the transcript or simply apply it to those courses. If you use an unweighted scale, however, and omit the pluses and minuses, you’ll want to stay with that choice for all courses, even those from other institutions.
In short, choose one grading scale that best represents your student’s academic journey and use it consistently for all four years of high school. This way, you ensure fairness and clarity.
Step 4: Consider College Admissions may Recalculate
An important thing to keep in mind is that many college admissions offices recalculate GPAs to fit their own standards. This means that slight variations in your grading approach, such as whether to include plus and minus grades, whether you weighted grades, etc. However, maintaining transparency and consistency on your transcript helps colleges more easily understand your grading approach, which can reflect well on your homeschooling program.
Step 5: Make an Informed Decision and Document Your Grading Policy
After you’ve made a decision, consider documenting your grading policy. Including a brief “Grading Scale” in the student’s transcript footer can provide context for admissions officers, explaining how you’ve converted grades from different institutions and applied a consistent scale. For instance, you could state:
“Grades for all courses are recorded on a 4.0 scale. Grades from dual enrollment providers have been converted according to this scale to maintain consistency across the student’s academic record.”
This small addition provides clarity and helps prevent any questions about discrepancies in grading.
BIG Transcript Program ($99 Lifetime access!)
The BIG Transcript Class is the foundation you need to prepare a well-constructed, college or career-ready homeschool transcript in all 50 states. More than a transcript course, the BIG program teaches you how to properly evaluate and record regular and honors credit, online and on-campus college coursework, and credit by exam such as CLEP and AP. You’ll learn to calculate GPA with precision, align your transcript with college, NCAA, and Common App expectations, and manage your student’s academic paper trail with confidence. Enrollment includes lifetime access to the BIG Transcript Hub, featuring HS4CC transcript examples, course titles, descriptions, tools, and ongoing resources.
Register now
